At one point in “Figaro Up Figaro Down,” Tim Blevins recalls that he was going to major in animal studies in college before finding his true calling as an opera singer, having a hulking stage presence to go with a booming voice. It would not be the only time life would prove to have other plans for him in spite of the success he had treading the boards in New York where he would land roles on Broadway after training at Julliard, giving himself as much over to a crippling drug habit as he would his go-for-broke performances. When director Javid Soriano finds him on the streets of San Francisco, he is continuing down that unsustainable path when he remains hopelessly addicted to drugs – not only taking them, but selling them as well when there are few other ways for him to make easy money in his state – but will still belt out a professional level “Nessun Dorma” at the drop of a hat, summoning an undefeated soul no matter how beleaguered he may look from having to look for a new place to stay each night.
That there is some refuge in classical music for Blevins gives an interesting twist to Soriano’s decision to film his current situation in stark black-and-white, an artful presentation of a hard-scrabble existence that at once is unforgiving and yet where Blevins feels most at home when to change anything about it seems impossible. There are some thorny moral questions as to what Soriano must set aside personally to depict Blevins’ plight, evading the cops on a nightly basis in seeking shelter and seen in the moments before shooting up on camera with the help of his girlfriend Melinda, but the film nonetheless brings out the opera singer’s gentle spirit in a tender portrait where it becomes clear that addiction doesn’t necessarily happen in a vacuum.
Hobbled by a decaying hip likely as a result of his drug use, Blevins has retained the magnetism that made him a star on stage even when he’s only singing for his supper, but as Soriano slowly reveals, he’s carrying a lot else with him despite having few material possessions of his own. (A fight with Melinda, only recently released from prison, is precipitated by the fact that the grocery cart she hauls around grows ever mountainous.) He remains sporadically connected to his family, but they like all of his professional peers found him increasingly unreliable as his addiction really took hold and keep their distance, from his ex-wife Liz and daughter Joaquina (his son Max won’t speak to him at all) to his mother Kathy and father Bobby, who regrets now being too much of a disciplinarian when his son was younger when perhaps a lack of freedom to be himself led to chemical dependency.
It’s an admission that both isn’t inaccurate, but also not entirely complete as Soriano teases out a history of addiction that predates Tim’s drug use and beyond having a compelling subject at its center when in spite of losing everything, Blevins still pursues his passion, the film demonstrates in fascinating fashion how self-inhibited others become around a junkie, elucidating the queasy feeling they have of perhaps failing him out of a desire to protect themselves. (As Liz remarks, accepting Tim’s denials of drug abuse when clearly something was amiss may have been self-denial on some level.)
Flashbacks to Blevins’ life before it all fell apart may be in lower definition (just ahead of HD cameras at the turn of the 21st century), but they offer bursts of color for the primary monochrome film, one stylistic flourish of many that Soriano employs to affords dignity to him as he navigates hard times. (One of the film’s highlights is a dream sequence involving flashes of all the family members Tim has put out of his reach before they’re formally introduced, a result of savvy structuring that’s evident throughout.) Even at a succinct 80 minutes, it can feel at times that the film can be stretching as it observes Blevins stumbling through for better and worse – opportunity comes his way in the form of a live performance, but both the uncertainty of life as a transient and whether he can or wants to get the help he needs to get clean could get in the way – but in fact, it’s the singer and not the song that rises to the occasion when Soriano shows as much innate talent as Blevins does in illuminating someone both soulful and complicated.
“Figaro Up Figaro Down” will screen at DOC NYC at the Village East on November 19th at 4:15 pm and will be available on DOC NYC’s online platform.